Skip to content 
Picking right impeller design is a very important decision for commercial or industrial uses. Both centrifugal & axial impellers have different benefits as well as limitations.
In this comparison blogpost we will guide you through their important differences that will help you to make best decision for your particular requirements.
What are Centrifugal Impellers?
Centrifugal impellers serve as the main rotating component in centrifugal pumps. These components convert mechanical energy into fluid motion through their design. They feature curved blades or vanes between shroud plates. This design directly affects three important pump characteristics that are pressure capabilities, flow rate of pump and solid handling capacity.
What are Axial Impellers?
An axial impeller works like a propeller that moves fluid along its shaft. It has aerodynamic blades extending from a central hub. The motor transfers rotational energy through these parts which produces axial flow. These impellers are big fluid moving systems that work best in low to medium pressure operations.
Top 10 Main Differences between Centrifugal & Axial Impellers
1. Structure and Design
Centrifugal impellers have backward curved or straight radial vanes between shroud plates. Their main parts are volute casing, impeller eye and diffuser section. The shrouded design stops tip leakage losses and the spiral volute diverts fluid towards discharge nozzle.
Axial impellers feature aerodynamically twisted runner blades on a teardrop shaped hub. Their design includes stator guide vanes, variable pitch blade assemblies and a flow straightening system. All elements work together to maximize flow dynamics through hub to tip ratios & blade solidity ratios.
2. Flow and Pressure Characteristics
Centrifugal impellers provide low flow rates but are good at producing high pressures. Radial discharge patterns convert kinetic energy of fluid into pressure energy at volute. This process can achieve pressure heads up to 300 kPa although it limits overall flow capacity.
Axial impellers give high flow rates at low pressures. Their direct design uses aerodynamic principles like airplane wings. This allows large volumes of fluid to be moved efficiently. However they can not produce high pressures like centrifugal impellers.
3. Direction of Flow
Centrifugal impellers form a radial flow pattern. Fluid enters from center and exits outwards at an angle formed by the rotation of shaft. Centrifugal force is generated on the rotor which pushes the fluid out of the eye of impeller towards the casing.
Axial impellers keep fluid motion parallel to the shaft. The propeller like design creates a consistent flow pattern along the axis of the shaft. Fluid moves through the impeller in a straight path with less radial movement. Aerodynamic blades decrease roughness and gives smooth flow.
4. Weight & Size
Centrifugal impellers have a greater overall size because of volute casing. Their radial flow path requires more space. These design elements lead to a massive structure in contrast to axial alternatives.
Direct flow configurations make axial impellers light in weight & compact as well. They do not require a volute casing which decreases their housing size and front area. This smooth structure uses lesser material that results in lower weight.
5. Power Consumption
Centrifugal impellers have an efficiency level of approximately 60%. Their high pressure needs and complicated flow paths affect this rating. These impellers require more power as operational speed increases. System characteristics and impeller diameter directly affect their efficiency.
Axial impellers achieve efficiencies of about 70%. Their streamline flow patterns require less power input for equal flow rates. These impellers maintain constant efficiency under varying flow conditions. However high component surface roughness can decrease their efficiency.
6. Maintenance Requirements
Centrifugal impellers are maintained on a strict schedule. Monthly inspections focus on the condition of bearings and weekly checks detect any leakage. Moreover complete dismantling is necessary for component replacement every 1 to 2 years. Some maintenance protocols are detailed inspections of shaft seals, wear rings and impeller blades.
Axial impellers have a simpler maintenance procedure. The main task is to clean the blades with wire brushes & dusting. Regular balance checks guarantee better performance. Lubrication needs to be done every 6 months. Their straightforward configuration lowers requirement for extensive repairs in contrast to centrifugal models.
7. Operational Speed
Axial impellers work at notably high speeds which are often greater than 9000 rpm. Their design requires these speeds to attain appropriate flow rates. Modern speed control systems prevent vibration problems at these speeds.
Centrifugal impellers operate efficiently between 300 to 3000 rpm. They use centrifugal force to increase the speed of fluid. Their radial design achieves the necessary flow rates and pressure heads at these moderate speeds.
8. Noise Levels
The noise of centrifugal impellers reaches 75 dB. This high noise is due to two main reasons which are irregular flow pattern & complicated structure. A change of flow direction at 90° creates inlet flow disturbance. The casing adds 10 dB to the total noise above 100 Hz.
Axial impellers operate at low noise levels of approximately 60 dB. Their direct flow path & well organized design contribute to quiet operation. Here impeller is the main source of noise not casing. Proper installation is needed for better acoustic performance because upstream flow conditions affect noise production.
9. Cost
Centrifugal impellers range in price from $20 to $6000 per unit that depends on application & size. Common industrial models cost about $100. Special high pressure units for chemical processing can cost up to $4000. The choice of material has a great impact on cost. For example special alloys & stainless steel are mostly more expensive.
Standard configurations for axial impeller range in price from $1800 to $2500 per unit. Prices increase with particular performance requirements and diameter size. Industrial units with diameters greater than 900 mm can cost over $10000 specially for high flow applications.
10. Uses
Oil refineries, chemical processing plants and water treatment facilities are heavily dependent on centrifugal impellers. These units maintain high pressure differentials and efficiently handle crucible fluids. Industries with strict contamination control & varying fluid properties benefit from this design.
Axial impellers are used in flood control systems, power plants and large scale irrigation projects. Their design is great in mining operations, water circulation and crystallization processes. These impellers work best in applications where steady liquid circulation is needed with low pressure requirements.
Advantages & Disadvantages of Centrifugal vs. Axial Impellers
Centrifugal Impellers
Advantages
- One main advantage of centrifugal impellers is their ability to create high pressures. This makes them an excellent choice for fluid systems that demand high pressures like gas and chemical processing systems as well as water pumps.
- The design of centrifugal pumps permits for multi stage operations. Users can connect multiple units in series to achieve higher head and pressure in booster applications.
- These impellers are highly flexible to a variety of industries. They can efficiently process liquids & gases in water treatment plants, HVAC systems and other industrial uses.
Disadvantages
- The risk of cavitation remains a constant concern. When the liquid pressure drops below the vapor pressure then components of appliance will be damaged.
- Condensed liquids are a major challenge for centrifugal impellers. These condensed liquids reduce flow rates and efficiency during operation.
Axial Impellers
Advantages
- The operational design of axial impellers minimizes wear and mechanical stress. As a result they give better durability and maintain dependable performance during continuous operations.
- These impellers give high flow rates with low energy consumption. This characteristic makes them particularly suitable for use cases that need elevated flow rates like air handling systems.
- They have fluid motion that is straighter and consistent. This design decreases fluid mixing and produces less shear stress as opposed to centrifugal models.
Disadvantages
- Performance stability is highly dependent on fluid consistency and accurate blade perspective. Even slight changes in these factors can lead to performance downfall, flow unsteadiness or stalling.
- Debris and solid particles create operational problems for axial impellers. Straight flow patterns do not have sufficient turbulence to remove or suspend particles.
Centrifugal vs. Axial Impellers – Which One to Choose?
These impellers should be selected according to your intended use. Centrifugal impellers are great in use cases like chemical processing, high pressure operations or systems where flow direction alters. Their design guarantees reliable performance under non uniform pressure conditions.
On the other hand, systems where high flow rate with low head pressure is needed, axial impellers offer the best solution. These applications include flood control, cooling systems and irrigation projects.
You should evaluate maintenance requirements, available space and operational cost before making a decision. Axial impellers’ straight line flow path & complicated design make them perfect for continuous fluid movement applications that require low pressure.
To Sum Up
Industrial applications benefit from both impeller designs. Axial impellers are best in situations where high flow fluid movement is required. While robust construction of centrifugal impellers makes them perfect for high pressure applications.
If you are interested in the shape and structure of the impeller, we recommend that you read this article: What are the Main Differences Between an Open, Semi-Open and Closed Impeller?
If you require any kind of custom impeller manufactured–centrifugal, axial, etc-, then RICHCONN is best option. You can contact us anytime.
Related Questions
What is importance of diameter of an impeller?
Diameter of impeller performs a big role in efficiency of pump. A larger diameter increases flow rates and produces higher pressure heads. However it also affects power consumption and overall efficiency of pump.
What is role of impeller in centrifugal compressor?
In centrifugal compressors impeller acts as energy converter. Its rotating vanes create a centrifugal force that accelerates gas outward in a radial direction. This process converts mechanical energy into velocity & fluid pressure.
How does impeller speed affect pump performance?
The rotational speed of the impeller determines its efficiency output. As the speed decreases, impeller transfers more kinetic energy to the fluid. This improved energy transfer increases flow capacity and discharge pressure rises.
How does number of blades on an impeller affect its function?
Number of blades creates a tradeoff between flow rate and stability. More blades guarantee smoother operation but increases frictional losses. On the other hand fewer blades allow more flow rates through the impeller.
Can impellers be customized for specific applications?
Impellers give numerous personalization options. Engineers can select specific materials, change blade geometry and apply different surface treatments. These adjustments help impeller adapt to fluid characteristics and different operating conditions.
