Skip to content 
Many industries depend on various processes. Welding is one of them. In these sectors, two welding gasses are most common. They are MIG welding and TIG Welding. Each method has distinct advantages and applications.
This article examines the specifics of MIG and TIG welding. It outlines its procedures, tools, operating principles, and metal transfer types.
Overview of MIG Welding
Metal Inert Gas welding is mainly termed MIG Welding. Continuous wire feed electrodes are used in this welding method. Weld pools are sealed with argon or gas mixture to avoid contamination.
As wire passes past the welding gun, metals melt and fuse. The speed and strength of MIG welding are remarkable. Discover more about MIG welding below:
1. Process Explanation
Multiple processes are involved in MIG welding that make it successful. The equipment is first set up by the welder, who checks the gas supply and wire spool connections. After fine-tuning voltage and wire feed speed, welding may begin.
The gas and wire feed are turned on when the welder aims the gun at the metal junction. The electric arc between the wire and workpiece melts the wire and base metal edges. Thus creating a molten pool that solidifies and forms a strong bond.
2. Components of MIG Welding Equipment
MIG welding equipment has numerous essential parts. The welding equipment is the most crucial since it powers the operation. This machine is hooked up to a wire feeder. The wire feeder holds the welding wire and controls its speed.
The welder uses a cannon with an ignition electrode and a nozzle to transport shielding gas. Protective gear like hats and gloves are needed to protect the burner from UV rays and spatter.
3. Working Principle
MIG welding creates an electric spark that melts the welding wire and metal pieces. The electric current runs through the wire when the welder fires the gun. It makes a line of electricity between the wire and the base metal.
The high heat from this arc melts the metal and forms a puddle. The protective gas moves around the weld area to keep it clean from dirt and dust in the air. Then, the welder pushes the gun along the joint, making the liquid metal harden. This process creates a durable and robust weld.
4. Types of Metal Transfer
There are different ways to transfer metal during MIG welding. Each MIG welding metal transfer method modifies the procedure. The most common types are spray, short-circuit, and globular transfer. In short-circuit transfer, the wire touches the workpiece and shorts out. Thus allowing for low heat input and better control, which is ideal for thin materials.
Globular transfer employs larger molten metal droplets. It does better with thicker materials, although it splatters more. Spray transfer is best for bigger pieces of metal. When used with high heat, it creates a smooth, stable arc with little spray.
Overview of TIG Welding
Metal joining is accurate and versatile in TIG welding. It’s used in sectors that value strong, attractive welds. TIG welding is unique because it can create clean and exact welds on various metals. Learn more about TIG welding below:
1. Process Explanation
A tungsten electrode is welded to the piece being welded, and an electric arc forms between them. This arc’s intense heat melts the base metal, making a pool for the join. The welder adds filler to the pool by hand if it’s needed. A neutral gas stream, usually argon, keeps the weld area clean.
The welder has a foot pump that controls the current, which lets the exact amount of heat be put in. With this much control, TIG welding is perfect for doing delicate work on thin materials. They are ideal for creating visually appealing welds on visible surfaces.
2. Components of TIG Welding Equipment
TIG welding requires various components, but the torch is the major one. It retains the tungsten electrode and directs the protective gas. The electricity comes from a power source and can be AC or DC. It is based on the metal being fused. The harmless shielding gas comes from gas tanks.
Another necessary part is a foot pedal for controlling the current. It also has a cooling system for the torch. Different tungsten electrodes and filler pieces are also essential parts. A high-frequency starter may help start the arc without touching the wire to the object.
3. Role of Tungsten Electrode
In TIG welding, the tungsten anode is very important. This electrode doesn’t melt or become part of the metal as MIG welding does. Instead, it’s only used to make and keep the electric spark going. The high melting point of tungsten makes it resistant to welding spark heat.
There are several tungsten electrodes. They often have small amounts of materials like thorium or cerium. These chemicals can make the spark more stable and easier to start. They also have the capability of making the electrode last longer. The electrode to use depends on things like the metal being fused and power usage.
Pros and Cons of MIG Welding
Job suitability depends on MIG welding’s benefits and downsides. Below are its pros and cons:
Pros
Here are the key advantages of using MIG Welding:
- Speed: It is faster than other welding methods.
- Learning ease: Learning it is simpler than TIG welding. Hence, even less experienced welders can work with it.
- Versatility: MIG can join a lot of different metals and sizes.
- Less cleanup: It makes less slag than some other welding ways. So it takes less time to clean up after the weld.
- Continuous welding: The wire feed in this process allows for long, uninterrupted welds.
Cons
MIG Welding has its key benefits. Yet, it also has some disadvantages. Below are some MIG Welding cons:
- Less precise: MIG welding has poorer weld control than TIG. It can be a problem when working with very thin materials or with great accuracy.
- Potential for defects: MIG welding can cause problems like holes or lack of fusion if it’s not done right.
- Limited use outdoors: The wind can blow away the protective gas.
- Equipment bulk: MIG welding gear can be heavy.
Pros and Cons of TIG Welding
Pros
The following are a few benefits of employing the TIG welding procedure:
- Accuracy: TIG offers excellent control. So it creates accurate, high-quality welds.
- Clean welds: Slag and dust are absent from TIG welds. After welding, welders only need to clean up.
- Versatility: This method can weld almost any metal. It includes thin materials and dissimilar metals.
Cons
TIG welding offers benefits and downsides. Here are its drawbacks:
- Lower speed: MIG welding is faster than TIG. It can make work less efficient.
- Difficulty: It requires more skill and practice to master.
- Equipment Cost: TIG setups tend to be more expensive.
- Limited to thinner materials: TIG works best on thin materials but not thick ones.
Fatigue: The need for accuracy might make welders tired after long sessions.
Applications of MIG Welding
MIG welding plays a vital role across many industries due to its versatility and efficiency. It’s a top choice for automotive applications, such as welding car bodies and frames, and is favored on high-volume production lines for its ability to create strong welds quickly. Auto repair shops also use MIG welding to repair damaged car parts.
In the construction industry, MIG welding is essential for joining structural steel beams and columns in building frameworks, as well as for manufacturing durable components for bridges. It’s also extensively used in shipbuilding to construct and repair hulls, thanks to its compatibility with the thick steel plates used in ships.
Manufacturing is another sector where MIG welding shines, as it is employed to produce a wide range of metal products, including industrial tools, equipment, and furniture. This welding technique works well with various metals, such as steel and aluminum, making it suitable for aerospace applications to fabricate airplane and spacecraft components.
MIG welding is also crucial in agriculture for the production and repair of farming equipment like tractors and harvesters. The strength of MIG welds ensures these tools can withstand the harsh conditions of agricultural work.
Applications of TIG Welding
Many industries need TIG welding. It creates parts in the aerospace industry. TIG welding makes solid and clean welds for light aviation metals. Engine components, fuel systems, and structural sections of airplanes require precision work.
Medical instruments and surgical tools are made using TIG welding. Health-compliant devices benefit from clean, precise TIG welds. It helps make implants, limbs, and other medical devices. Automotive manufacturers also favor TIG welding for high-end and performance automobiles. It produces parts like exhaust systems and roll cages.
The food and drink sector uses various TIG-welded processing tools. It cleans and prevents rust in stainless steel tanks, pipes, and fitting joints. Also, in the energy industry, TIG welding is needed. It is used to build and fix up power plants, especially nuclear ones. TIG makes solar panel and wind turbine components for green energy industries.
MIG vs TIG Welding – 9 Major Differences
You must understand the differences between MIG and TIG welding to determine the optimal method. Let’s cover the 9 significant differences between these welding processes:
1. Electrodes Used
Electrodes move electricity around, make electric sparks, or fill in gaps. Two electrodes are used in electric arc welding. These are the consumable and non-consumable. Both types of electrodes make electric sparks.
Consumable electrodes are filled and consumed during welding. The metal electrode melts and forms part of the MIG weld. As the electrode and filler, this wire runs through the welding gun by itself.
TIG welding employs a non-melting tungsten spark to create the arc. Welders manually add filler metal from a rod to the weld pool. This main difference shapes how each method works and what it can accomplish.
2. Weld Strength
TIG welding usually produces superior welds than MIG. It creates high-quality parts that hold up well under stress. That’s because it offers precise control and deep penetration. TIG welding produces crisp, flaw-free welds. Most experts prefer TIG welds because they go deeper and have fewer defects.
MIG welds are still strong enough for most applications. But, they may not achieve the same level of penetration or strength. MIG welding’s strength is generally enough for most industrial and commercial uses. Factors other than pure strength often play a bigger role in the decision.
3. Power Source
Direct current (DC) with reverse voltage is usually used for MIG welding. The power settings mainly change the strength and speed of the wire feed. AC and DC electricity can be used for TIG welding, which offers more power choices.
DC is better for metals like steel and aluminum, while AC is better for materials like aluminum. TIG is helpful because it can use different power sources, but it is also more complex to master.
4. Weld Speed
There is no doubt that MIG welding is faster. Since it feeds wire continuously, it can weld faster. That makes it great for production work and bigger projects.
With MIG welding, a qualified worker may finish a task faster than TIG welding. The latter takes longer than MIG. That’s because the welder has to watch the torch and feed the filler rod manually carefully.
Air-cooled TIG torches can overheat during long welds. Moving to costly, hard-to-use water-cooled flashlights may be necessary. This slower pace helps TIG be more precise, but it slows down output.
5. Welding Gas
Both processes use shielding gasses, but their types and purposes differ slightly. For steel, MIG welding sometimes only uses carbon dioxide. But most of the time, it uses a mix of oxygen and carbon dioxide. The choice of gas changes how well the weld and penetration work.
Pure argon or sometimes helium-argon mixes are used for TIG welding. Pure argon makes the spark more stable and the welds cleaner. It is essential for applications that require TIG welding.
6. Cooling System
A more complex cooling device is usually needed for TIG welding than MIG welding. Water is often used to cool TIG flames since the tungsten electrode gets hot. This is especially true when working with a lot of amps.
MIG welding typically uses air-cooled guns. However, there’s an exception for very high-amperage industrial applications. This difference changes both the cost of the tools and how hard it is to set up.
7. Weldable Metals
Joining metals using TIG welding is excellent. It works well with materials like aluminum and stainless steel. It is very good at joining thin materials and metals that are not the same.
MIG welding works on many metals. It works best with aluminum, mild steel, and stainless steel. It might have trouble with very thin materials or certain alloys. This difference often tells us which process is best for a specific job.
8. Weld Appearance
TIG welding makes cleaner lines and looks better than MIG welding. Smooth, little-spatter weld beads result from clean processing and precise control. MIG welding can create lines that look good. Unlike TIG welding, its results are usually less clean and have more splatter. TIG is often the best choice for apparent welds where looks are important.
9. Cost
The cost of the tools and the labor for MIG welding is usually less than that for TIG welding. MIG welders cost less, and the simpler process needs fewer accessories.
The cooling device and different tools needed for TIG welding are more expensive. But, TIG’s accuracy could save money on projects that need perfect welds. All thanks go to its ability to reduce the need for extra work.
MIG vs TIG Welding – How to Choose the Right Method?
Choosing a procedure involves numerous factors. Making the correct choice saves time and money and helps the job go better. Below are essential factors when choosing between MIG and TIG Welding:
1. Project requirements
The optimum welding procedure depends on the project. TIG welding produces precise, high-quality welds. It is excellent for essential things like medical tools or parts for spacecraft. It works incredibly well for thin materials and visible welds where appearance matters.
MIG welding is better for jobs that need to be finished quickly. It’s also suitable for jobs that need to work with stronger materials.
2. Material considerations
Different metals respond better to specific welding processes. TIG welding can be used on a bigger range of metals, such as explosive metals like titanium. It works well with stainless steel and thin metal.
Common metals, like mild steel and stronger aluminum, work best for MIG welding. TIG welding is helpful for jobs that use more than one type of metal or a unique combination. But MIG welding is still great for making simple things out of steel.
3. Skill level
The welding experience of the welder can influence the choice. MIG welding is easier to learn and better for people just starting. After a few weeks of practice, most people can learn MIG welding basics.
TIG welding takes more skill and timing and can take months to get good at it. MIG is usually a better way to start for new welders unless the job needs TIG.
4. Budget
The budget includes more than just the cost of the tools. Although MIG welders usually cost less at first, consider ongoing expenses. These include costs like shielding gas, wire, and maintenance.
However, the initial cost of TIG welding tools is higher. It needs extra parts like different electrodes and filler rods. On precise weld operations, TIG welding may save money in the long term by reducing rework.
5. Production volume
The needs of the production process significantly affect the choice of welding. MIG welding fits high-volume production with its welding speed and constant wire feed. It lets the user weld continuously for longer with less fatigue.
TIG welding is slower but works better for high-precision, low-volume work. These are jobs where quality is more important than speed. Consider the output plan and the required work when choosing between these methods.
FAQs:
1. Which Process Is More Expensive – MIG or TIG Welding?
Setting up and using TIG welding costs more than MIG welding. TIG equipment has more parts, like special torches and different wires. Also, protective gasses cost more, and finishing the welds takes longer. MIG welding uses less expensive tools and speeds up output, reducing labor costs. The final price will rely on the purpose and quality needs.
2. Can You Weld Aluminum With Both MIG and TIG?
There are two ways to weld metal, but each works best in specific scenarios. TIG welding is excellent for joining thin sheets of metal together. It makes lines that are cleaner, stronger, and look better. It offers more control over the heat that goes in. It is essential to keep the thin metal from burning through.
MIG welding is better for making many things out of thick metal. It requires an aluminum wire spool gun but finishes faster than TIG welding.
3. Which Process Creates Stronger Welds – MIG or TIG Welding?
TIG welding usually produces stronger welds than MIG. It improves welding penetration and precision. Its heat input management ensures constant, high-quality welds with good fusion.
But, when done right, MIG welding can create strong welds for most applications. Weld strength depends more on the welder’s skill and attention than the procedure. Both methods can make stronger welds than the base material if done correctly.
Final Thoughts!
Both MIG and TIG welding are critical in many different fields. MIG welding is fast and easy to use. Hence, it is excellent for large-scale output and less-skilled workers. Its adaptability makes welding common metals efficient, especially in automobiles.
TIG welding, on the other hand, is very accurate and of good quality. It better applies to difficult jobs and materials like aluminum and stainless steel. Its careful process produces cleaner, better-looking welds.
At Richconn, our certified team is skilled in both MIG and TIG welding. From aerospace components to sheet metal fabrication, we bring experience to every weld. Contact us to discuss your projects that involve MIG and TIG welding.
