Skip to content 
Impellers are one of the important parts in a pumping system. They commonly come in three main types: There are open, semi open, and closed designs. Today we will look at the differences between these impeller types in design, benefits and application.
What are Open Impellers?
As the name says, open impellers have an open design which means the vanes attach directly to a central hub and lack shrouds or side-walls.
Their open structure enables fluids to pass freely through them which is appropriate for liquid with debris or solids. But these impellers lack robustness compared to other types of impellers because of lack of structural support on both sides.
Advantages
- Simplified cleaning: Open impeller has an open design that allows all parts to be exposed. So maintenance and cleaning tasks are easy.
- Efficient handling: They have a lower tendency to clog and are therefore very good at pumping fluids that contain suspended debris or solids.
- Adaptability: These can be used for a broad range of fluid viscosities and that’s why they get used in number of industries such as food processing and wastewater treatment.
Disadvantages
- Reduced efficiency: The absence of enclosed vanes results in fluid leakage and lower hydraulic efficiency than other impeller types.
- Increased vulnerability: Due to their open structure they are more prone to damage and wear when handling abrasive materials or when operating in high pressure environment.
Applications of Open Impellers
Open impellers are broadly used in industries such as those that handle fluids with high viscosity or suspended solids. Some of their applications include:
Wastewater Treatment
At wastewater treatment plants, open impellers are used to pump sludge, sewage, and other fluids containing solid debris. Their open design minimizes the chance of clogging and enhances the operation in these difficult environments.
Food and Beverage Processing
Open impellers are used in the food and beverage industry for transferring liquids with suspended particles such as grains or fruit pulp. Their easy cleaning helps them to meet the hygiene standard requirements for these applications.
Chemical Processing
In chemical processing tasks where fluids may have abrasives or small solids, open impellers are very effective. They are used for pumping viscous or corrosive chemicals with good reliability.
Mining
Open impellers are used by mining operations to handle slurries of gravel, sand or other solids. They give a practical choice for mineral processing and dewatering applications because of their ability to deal with abrasive materials.
Agricultural Irrigation
Open impellers are used in agricultural irrigation systems where they pump water with organic matter or sediments. They are designed robustly to continue to perform even when there is debris in water.
What are Semi-Open Impellers?
The semi open impellers have a distinct design that takes characteristics of the open and also the closed impellers. The core of the impeller is a central hub to which vanes are attached on one side. The other side remains open. Additional strength is given to the vanes by a back wall shroud that partially encloses them. The design is easy to clean as well as durable. Semi open impellers are mostly suitable for medium sized pumps that pump fluids containing small amount of soft solids.
Advantages
- Balanced efficiency: Semi open impellers give a good compromise between closed and open impellers. Efficiency and NPSH are balanced well by them.
- Adjustable: Semi open impeller’s clearance between impeller and pump casing can be adjusted. This enables performance optimization.
- Solids handling capabilities: These impellers are good at passing moderate amounts of suspended solids without blocking.
Disadvantages
Semi-open impellers_despite their versatility_have some limitations, which are:
- Irregular flow patterns: The semi-open impeller has more turbulent flow compared to a fully enclosed impeller.
- Potential for reduced efficiency: In these impellers, the gap between the impeller and casing causes fluid recirculation. It may slightly lower efficiency overall.
Main Applications
The semi-open impellers are used by many industries. These are:
Chemical processing
Corrosive fluids and solutions containing small solids are well handled by semi-open impellers. They are commonly used by chemical plants for mixing and transferring reactive substances.
Oil and gas
Semi open impellers are used in the gas and oil industry for pumping crude oil and other petroleum products. Their design is efficient for dealing with fluids that have some suspended particles.
Food processing
Semi open impellers are suitable for slurries and viscous liquids in food production. They are used commonly in processing of purees, sauces and other food products with moderate solids content.
Wastewater treatment
In wastewater treatment plants, semi-open impellers are very important. They can pump water with small solids and debris efficiently which makes them useful for different treatment processes.
What are Closed Impellers?
Closed impellers are completely enclosed within two parallel disks (a front cover and a rear cover). This design of closed impeller creates a sealed channel that directs fluid flow from the impeller eye to the outer edge. The front cover faces the suction inlet and the motor is closer to the rear cover. Curved vanes located inside the enclosed space guide the fluid’s path and have an important effect on the impeller performance.
Advantages
- Highest efficiency: Closed impeller minimizes fluid recirculation and energy loss and therefore provides superior efficiency than open and semi-open impellers.
- High pressure applications: Closed impellers are good for generating high pressure and head for high demanding pumping applications.
- Better structural support: The additional wall sections on both sides of the vanes make the impeller stronger. It reduces shaft load and enhances general durability.
- Handling clean fluids: These impellers are designed for industries that need contamination free fluid handling because they work very well with clean liquids.
Disadvantages
- Challenging to clean: Due to the fact that the design is enclosed it is difficult to access the internal components of impeller for cleaning or maintenance without disassembling the pump.
- Higher manufacturing costs: Closed impellers are more complex in design and therefore cost more to produce than open or semi-open impellers.
- Not suitable for fluids with solids: Closed impellers are restricted from some applications because they tend to clog when the liquid contains particulate matter or debris.
Closed Impeller’s Applications
Closed impellers are commonly used in:
High pressure cleaning equipment
Closed impellers generate the strong, steady water flow. This is needed for effective cleaning in pressure washers.
Water supply systems
Closed impellers are used to efficiently pump clean water from reservoirs to businesses and homes within municipal water distribution networks.
Boiler feed pumps
In power plants, closed impellers are needed to move high-pressure, high-temperature water into boilers for steam generation.
Petroleum refining
Closed impellers are used in the oil and gas industry for transporting refined products. Their enclosed design prevents fluid leakage and maintains high efficiency in important processes.
Comparative Analysis
Now let’s compare open, semi-open and closed impellers.
Solids Handling
Open Impellers are less likely to clog therefore good at handling solids. Moderate solids content can be handled by semi open impellers. Clean fluids with minimal solids are best dealt with closed impellers.
Efficiency
For clean fluids the most efficient impeller is closed impeller. Open impellers have the lowest efficiency due to leakage whereas semi open impellers have balanced efficiency.
Cost Implications
Impellers with open design are the cheapest to manufacture. The cost for semi open impellers is moderate. And closed impellers are the most expensive because of their complicated design.
Maintenance Requirements
The easiest to clean and maintain are open impellers. Clearance adjustments must be made routinely for semi open impellers. Inspecting and cleaning closed impellers is difficult and the impeller must be disassembled for this.
A Full comparison table between open, semi-open and closed impellers
| Feature | Open Impeller | Semi-Open Impeller | Closed Impeller |
|---|---|---|---|
| Efficiency | Lowest | Moderate | Highest |
| Solids Handling | Best | Good | Limited |
| Maintenance | Easiest | Moderate | Most Difficult |
| Cost | Lowest | Moderate | Highest |
| NPSH Need | High | Moderate | Low |
| Structural Strength | Weak | Moderate | Strong |
| Inspection Ease | Excellent | Good | Poor |
| Clogging Risk | Low | Moderate | High |
| Manufacturing Complicatedness | Simple | Moderate | Complex |
| Design Flexibility | High | Moderate | Low |
Factors to Consider When Buying an Impeller
Operational Conditions
Select the right impeller type and size according to the required NPSH, head pressure and flow rate. Also take into consideration the operating cost and energy efficiency of impeller.
Fluid Characteristics
Chemical composition, viscosity, temperature and solids content of the fluid being pumped should be evaluated. This will affect impeller design and material choice.
Maintenance Considerations
Think about cleaning and maintenance requirements when selecting. Impellers that are open are easy to maintain whereas closed designs need more complicated servicing.
Economic Factors
Think about initial and long term costs also. Factor in:
- Manufacturing expense
- Maintenance costs
- Energy consumption
- Replacement part availability
- Expected lifespan
Conclusion
In short selecting the right impeller type is important for satisfactory pump operation. Solids handling is outstanding with open impellers; semi open impellers provide balanced performance and closed impellers give good efficiency with clean fluids.
If you need any kind of impeller -open, semi-open or closed- then RICHCON is your best option. You can contact us at any time.
FAQ’s
1. Why are closed impellers considered more efficient for clean fluids?
The closed impellers have both sides enclosed which reduce fluid bypass and increase hydraulic efficiency. Because of this design they are able to generate higher pressure with less energy and are good for handling clean fluids.
2. Which impeller type requires what maintenance consideration?
Open impellers are easiest to clean whereas semi open impellers need clearance adjustment. And closed impellers must be disassembled for inspection and servicing..
3. What effect do fluid viscosity and the presence of solids have on impeller selection?
Semi open or open impellers are often required for higher viscosity fluids in order to prevent clogging. For clean fluids of low solid content, closed impellers are more suitable.
4. What is the difference in tendency to clog between an open and a closed impeller?
Because of their design open impellers resist clogging better than closed impellers which are prone to blockages with solids.
5. Which impeller type is suitable for different pumping conditions and how does its structural strength affect it?
Closed impellers are suitable for high pressure applications and possess the maximum structural strength. Semi open impellers are a compromise between efficiency and strength. Open impellers are the weakest and better for low pressure situations.
